Gerald’s nagging doubts about his middle child’s appearance led him to request a paternity test, unaware that his life would turn upside down. The DNA test results caused irreparable damage to his 12-year marriage. It was a regular day when I found myself staring at my seven-year-old son’s school photo and searching for any trace of myself in his features. Aidan’s face stared back at me and made me realize how he looked so different from his brothers. That familiar knot in my stomach tightened as doubts crept into my mind.

Every time I looked at family photos, the contrast felt like a spotlight pointing at my darkest fears. I never thought these fears would ultimately ruin my life. Living in our suburban home with three beautiful boys and my amazing wife Julia, I had what most would call the American dream. My job as an IT project manager kept us comfortable, and after twelve years of marriage, Julia and I still had that spark. She was the kind of partner who’d leave silly love notes in my lunch box and laugh at my terrible dad jokes. We’d met at a friend’s barbecue, and I knew from our first conversation that she was special. When we got married two years later, I thought I couldn’t possibly love her more.

I’ll never forget the day Liam was born. Julia had been in labor for twenty-three hours, and when they finally placed him in my arms, my whole world shifted. He had the same deep-set brown eyes and the same slightly crooked smile. Even Julia’s mom couldn’t stop gushing about how much he looked like me..

“He’s definitely your son,” she’d say, laughing. “Poor Julia didn’t get a look in!” Watching Julia with our newborn son made me fall in love with her all over again. The way she handled those sleepless nights amazed me. I was honestly speechless looking at how she went through so much to bring our little one into this world. It made me respect my mother on a whole new level.

When Julia got pregnant with Aidan two years later, we were over the moon. I couldn’t wait to hold my second boy in my arms. However, things didn’t feel the same when Aidan was born and I looked at him for the first time. While Liam had been my mini-me, Aidan seemed to come from nowhere. He had pearl blonde hair while we were all dark-haired. His eye shape and color were totally different, and his smile wasn’t like mine at all.

“Babies change as they grow,” Julia had said when I mentioned it casually. “Remember how Liam looked completely different at three months? “Aidan was such a happy baby. He was always giggling and reaching for me when I came home from work. He grew into an energetic toddler who loved dinosaurs and could spend hours building elaborate block towers. I threw myself into being his dad, but that nagging feeling would creep in during quiet moments. Then came Owen last year. The moment I saw him, it was like seeing Liam all over again. The same eyes, the same nose, and even the same chin dimple.